Crypto-backed stablecoins: how they work and what can go wrong
Instead of a company holding dollars, you lock up more cryptocurrency than the coins you take out, and software enforces it.
The problem with the first kind is that you have to trust a company. This kind replaces the company with a program that anybody can read, running on a blockchain, which nobody can quietly change.
You put cryptocurrency into that program and it lets you borrow stablecoins against it. The catch is that you always have to put in more than you take out, often half as much again or more. Deposit 150 dollars of cryptocurrency, take out 100 stablecoins. That extra margin exists because cryptocurrency prices move, and the cushion is what keeps your 100 coins fully backed even on a bad day.
If the price of what you locked up falls far enough that the cushion is gone, the program sells your deposit automatically to cover the coins. That is called liquidation, it is not a punishment, and it is the mechanism that stops the system ever being under-backed.
A pawnbroker who only ever lends you two thirds of what your watch is worth, and sells the watch the moment it is worth less than what you owe.
What it rests on: The cushion being big enough, and the automatic selling actually working when markets are falling fast.
What can go wrong. A fast crash can outrun the system. Liquidation needs someone willing to buy the collateral right then. In a violent sell-off there may not be, and the coins can end up backed by less than they are worth. The code can have bugs. Trusting a program instead of a company means trusting that the program is correct. Mistakes in this kind of software have cost people everything they put in. It is capital-inefficient. Locking up 150 dollars to get 100 is fine for a trader and makes no sense for someone who just wants to be paid. This is why this kind never became the money ordinary people use.
Who it is actually for: People who specifically do not want a company in the middle, and who already hold cryptocurrency they do not want to sell.
A meaningful minority, used mostly inside crypto rather than for everyday payments. Also called: crypto-collateralised, over-collateralised, decentralised stablecoins. Examples: DAI, LUSD, crvUSD.